Nihil innovetur, nisi qud traditum est
"Yaan la helin wax cusub oo ka baxsan waxa la soo dhiibay."
— POPE Saint Stephen I (+ 257)
THE Oggolaanshaha Vatican-ka ee wadaaddadu si ay u barakaystaan lammaanaha isku jinsiga ah "lammaanaha" iyo kuwa xiriirka "aan caadiga ahayn" ayaa abuuray qallaf qoto dheer oo ka dhex jira Kaniisadda Katooliga.
Maalmo gudahood markii lagu dhawaaqay, ku dhawaad dhammaan qaaradaha (Africa), shirarka hoggaamiyaha kiniisaddu (tusaale. Hungary, Poland), Cardinal, iyo amarrada diinta diiday luqadda iska soo horjeeda ee Ducooyinka Fiducia (FS). Sida lagu sheegay war-saxaafadeed saaka ka soo baxay Zenit, "15 Shirar Episcopal ah oo ka socda Afrika iyo Yurub, oo lagu daray ku dhawaad labaatan degmo oo adduunka ah, waxay mamnuuceen, xaddideen, ama hakiyeen codsiga dukumeentiga ee dhulka diocuska, taasoo muujinaysa polarization-ka jira ee ku wareegsan."[1]Jan 4, 2024, Zenit A Wikipedia page ka dib markii ay ka soo horjeedaan Ducooyinka Fiducia hadda waxa lagu tiriyaa diidmada 16 shir kiniisadood, 29 qof oo kaardinal iyo kiniisadood, iyo todoba ururo iyo wadaado, diimeed, iyo ururo toos ah.
Bayaanka, oo sheegtay inuu saxeexay Pope, ayaa sidoo kale khilaafay bayaankiisii hore ee magisterial laba sano ka hor isaga oo ka jawaabaya su'aal (dubiya) weydiinaya haddii ururrada dadka isku jinsiga ah ay barakoobi karaan. Jawaabtu markaas waxay noqotay maya cad: kaliya shakhsiyaadka Waxay waydiisan kartaa duco maadaama ay u duceeyeen lammaanaha "ma muujinayso ujeedada ah in lagu aamino shakhsiyaadka noocaas ah ilaalinta iyo caawinta Ilaah ... laakiin in la oggolaado oo la dhiirigeliyo doorasho iyo hab nololeed oo aan la aqoonsan karin sida si macquul ah loogu amray Qorshayaasha Ilaah oo la muujiyey” (eeg Ma gees baan u rognay).
Jawaabta la soo jeediyay dubbe ["Kaniisadu ma leedahay awood ay ku siiso barakada ururada dadka isku jinsiga ah?"] kama reebayso barakooyinka la siiyo shakhsiyaadka leh khaniisnimada, kuwaas oo muujiya rabitaanka inay si daacad ah ugu noolaadaan qorshayaasha Ilaah ee la muujiyey sida ay soo jeedisay waxbaridda kaniisadda. Laakiin, waxay ku dhawaaqaysaa sharci darro wax kasta oo qaab duco ah oo u janjeerta inay aqoonsadaan ururradooda sida oo kale. -Jawaabta ee Jameecada Caqiidada Caqiidada ilaa shaki ku saabsan barakada ururada dadka isku jinsiga ah, Febraayo 22, 2021
Si kastaba ha ahaatee, dukumeentiga cusub wuxuu isku dayaa inuu sharciyeeyo nimcooyinka noocaas ah isagoo ereyga "midow" ku beddelaya "lammaan", taas oo caddaynaysa" suurtagalnimada barakaynta lammaanaha xaaladaha aan caadiga ahayn iyo lammaanaha isku jinsiga ah iyada oo aan si rasmi ah loo ansixin xaaladdooda ama aan isbeddelin sinaba waxbaridda joogtada ah ee Kaniisadda ee guurka. "[2]Ducooyinka Fiducia, Oo ku saabsan Macnaha Xoolo-dhaqatada soo bandhigida barakooyinka Laakiin wadaaddada adduunka oo dhan waxay isla markiiba dhalleeceeyeen ereyada sida "doublemined",[3]Emeritus Archbishop Charles Chaput "sophistry",[4]Fr. Thomas Weinandy iyo "dariiq khiyaano iyo khiyaano ah."[5]Bishop Athanasius Scheider
Waxaan xasuustaa markii laga doodayay sharciga trans-ka, in aanu ku dhex jirnay socod ka dhacayay St. Ignatius Parish oo ay qaar ka mid ah dadka ka guuray ay ii yimaaddeen barakadayda oo aan siiyey duco. [Waa] shay kale… in loo duceeyo lamaanaha khaniisiinta ah. Ma jiro hadda barakada dadka, laakiin lamaanaha, iyo dhaqanka kaniisadda oo dhan, xitaa dukumeenti laba sano ka hor, ayaa sheegaya in aysan suurtagal ahayn in tan la sameeyo. —Cardinal Daniel Sturla, Archbishop of Montevideo, Uruguay, Dec. 27, 2023,Hay'adda Catholic News
Mar haddii dukumeentigu ula dhaqmo la-hawlgalayaasha si sax ah iyadoo loo eegayo dhinaca xidhiidhka, kaas oo hawshiisa qeexideedu tahay mid hoose oo xun, waxa ku jira baaxadda barakada shay aan la barakaysan karin. — Dr. Christopher Malloy, Guddoomiyaha iyo Professor Fiqiga ee Jaamacadda Dallas, Diseembar 30, 2023; catholicworldreport.com
Dhab ahaantii, John Paul II wuxuu ka digay isku dayga cilmaaniga ah ee macnaha erayga "lammaan" ka soocay kala duwanaanshaha galmada:
Qiimaha kala dirid la'aanta guurka ayaa si isa soo taraysa loo diidayaa; dalabaadka waxaa loo sameeyaa aqoonsi sharci ah Qolyihii xidhiidhada sida in ay u dhigmaan guurka sharciga ah; waxaana la isku dayaa in la aqbalo qeexida lamaanaha taas oo farqiga jinsiga aan loo tixgelineynin muhiim. -Ecclesia ee Europe, n. 90, Juun 28, 2003
Weli qaar kale, sida hoggaamiyaha kiniisadda Kanada, waxay soo saareen tafsiir aad u wanaagsan iyagoo leh "Mabda'a hagaya ee Bayaanka ayaa ah xaqiiqda ah in codsiga barakada uu ka dhigan yahay furfurnaanta naxariista Ilaah waxayna noqon kartaa fursad aad loogu kalsoonaado Ilaah. ”[6]ccb.ca Si kastaba ha ahaatee, taasi waxay u malaynaysaa in lammaanaha - oo horeba ugu jiray xaalad dembi weyn - ay, dhab ahaantii, raadinayaan naxariista Ilaah. Oo haddii ay jiraan, tani waxay keenaysaa su'aal kale:
Maxay barakadan u weyddiinaysaan iyagoo lammaane ah, ee aanay sida qof keliya u baryin? Dabcan, qofka keligiis ah ee dhibaatadan ku haysata jacaylka isku jinsiga ah ayaa iman kara oo weydiisan kara duco si uu uga gudbo jirrooyinka, si uu u awoodo, nimcada Ilaah, inuu u noolaado si daahir ah. Laakiin kaligiis, lama iman doono lammaanaha - tani waxay noqon doontaa khilaaf ku saabsan jidkiisa si uu ugu noolaado sida Ilaah doonayo. —Bishop Athanasius Schneider, Diseembar 19, 2023; youtube.com
Maamulka Papal maroojin
Waxay u muuqataa ku dhawaad maalin kasta, wararka wadaado badan oo diidaya Ducooyinka Fiducia (FS) ayaa sameeya cinwaannada.[7]tusaale. Bishop Peruvian wuxuu mamnuucay barakooyinka isku jinsiga ah; lifesitenews.com; Wadaaddadii Isbaanishka oo bilaabay codsi ah in FS la buriyo; infovaticana-com; Wadaaddadii Jarmalku waxay diideen FS inay yihiin kuwo is burinaya, cf. lifesitenews.com Dhab ahaantii, cibaadada bari ee Kaniisadda Katooliga ayaa si cad u tidhi "maya" waxa FS ugu yeero "horumar cusub" barakooyinka.[8]cf. catholicherald.co.uk Tani waxay kicisay qalalaase aan hore loo arag halkaas oo hoggaamiyaha kiniisaddu ay ka soo horjeedaan dukumeenti, oo uu saxeexay baadari, oo ay ku yidhaahdeen "wax aan macquul ahayn" in loo fuliyo sida qoran.
Laakin tiro yar oo saameyn ku leh baraha bulshada ayaa weerar ku ah wadaad kasta ama caalim kasta oo ka walaacsan luqadda iska soo horjeeda ee FS. Waxay ku andacoonayaan in Magisterium (of Francis) uu hadlay, waa in si shaki la'aan ah loo adeeco, iyo in baadari uusan khaldami karin xitaa "magisterium caadiga ah."
Si kastaba ha ahaatee, dooddooda ayaa urta ultramontanism, bidcinimo casri ah oo awoodaha papal si weyn loo buunbuuniyay, oo ka hortagaya xadka soo jiidashada papal ee khalkhal la'aanta.
The Catechism ee Church Catholic ah wuxuu leeyahay:
Roman Pontiff, oo ah madaxa kuliyada kiniisadda, wuxuu ku raaxaystaa cillad la'aantan iyada oo loo eegayo xafiiskiisa, marka, sida wadaadka ugu sarreeya iyo macallinka dhammaan rumaysadka - kaas oo walaalihiis rumaysta ku xaqiijiya, wuxuu ku dhawaaqay ficil qeexan oo ku saabsan caqiido la xidhiidha iimaan ama akhlaaq... —N. 891
Tani waa ex cathedra ficil - laga bilaabo fadhiga Peter - iyo mid naadir ah taas. Dabcan, gadaalku markaa waa run, in baadari sidaas darteed noqon karo dhici karo marka uu adeegsado inta ka hartay awoodiisa waxbarida ama "magisterium."[9]Baadariyiinta ayaa sameeyay oo qaladaad sameeyay waana wax lala yaabo. Khalad la'aanta ayaa loo hayaa ex cathedra [“Kursiga” Butros, oo ah, ku dhawaaqida dogma ee ku saleysan Dhaqanka Xurmaysan]. No popes taariikhda Kaniisadda abid sameeyey ex cathedra khaladaadka. —Rev. Joseph Iannuzzi, fiqi iyo khabiir ku takhasusay wadaadada
Mid ka mid ah kiis noocaas ah ee taariikhda kaniisadda wuxuu ahaa Pope Honorius oo soo jeediyay in Masiixu leeyahay "hal dardaaran" (Kaniisadda, ka dib, waxay xaqiijisay sida caqiidada "labada dardaaran" Masiixa). Pope Agatho (678-681) ayaa mar dambe dhaleeceyn doona ereyada Honorius. Si kastaba ha ahaatee, halkan waa tusaale meesha uu baadari runtii noqon karo mid aan caddayn, madmadow, khalad, oo u baahan sixitaanka faylka. Kiiskii ugu dambeeyay ee baadari qalad fiqi ahaaneed wuxuu ahaa John XXII (1316 - 1334) markii uu baray aragtidiisa in quduusiintu ay ku raaxaysan doonaan aragtida quruxda badan ka dib xukunka ugu dambeeya ee imaatinka labaad ee Masiixa. Bishop Athanasius Schneider wuxuu xusay in daawaynta kiiskaas gaarka ah ee waqtiyadaas ay ahayd sidan soo socota: waxaa jiray waano dadweyne (Jaamacadda Paris, King Philip VI ee Faransiiska), diidmada aragtiyaha Papal ee khaldan ee lagu sameeyay daabacaadyo fiqi ahaaneed, iyo sixid walaalnimo ah. Isaga oo ka wakiil ah Cardinal Jacques Fournier, oo ugu dambeyntii noqday ku-xigeenkiisa Pope Benedict XII (1334-1342)."[10]Bishop Athanasius Schneider, onepeterfive.com
Ugu dambayntiina, waayaheenna, faallooyinka iyo ra'yiga tallaallada ama isbeddelka cimiladu kama dhigna waxbarashada kaniisadda mana aha akhlaaq ahaan ku xiran Masiixiyiinta rumaysadka leh maaddaama ay ka baxsan yihiin aragtida awoodda kiniisadda.[11]Wadaadka Joseph Iannuzzi, STL, S. Th.D., Warsidaha, Dayrta 2021; cf. Waxaa jira Hal Barque oo keliya
Baadarigu marka uu hadlayo ma samayn karo bidco ex cathedraTani waa caqiidada iimaanka. In waxbarashadiisa ka baxsan weedhaha cathedra ex, si kastaba ha ahaatee, wuxuu samayn karaa madmadow caqiido, khaladaad iyo xitaa bidcada. Oo tan iyo markii baadari ma aha mid la mid ah Kaniisadda oo dhan, Kaniisaddu way ka xoog badan tahay qalad keli ah ama Pope bidci ah. Xaaladdan oo kale waa in si xushmad leh loo saxo isaga (iyaga oo ka fogaanaya xanaaqa bini'aadamka iyo luqadda ixtiraam la'aanta), isaga caabbinta isaga sida mid uga hortagayo aabaha xun ee qoyska. Hase yeeshee, xubnaha qoysku ma sheegi karaan aabbahood sharka ah in laga saaray aabbanimada. Way hagaajin karaan isaga, diidi karaan inay addeecaan, way ka sooci karaan isaga.[12]ma aha kala qaybsanaan, laakiin waxaa cad in laga sooco wixii aan waafaqsanayn Dhaqanka Muqadaska ah. laakiin ma sheegi karaan in xilka laga qaaday. —Bishop Athansius Schneider, Sebtembar 19, 2023; onepeterfive.com
Halka qaarkood ay ku doodayaan in baadari uu noqon karo bidco,[13]cf. Pope-ka ma noqon karaa bidco? Catechismku way caddahay in baadari uu samayn karo khaladaad gaar ah oo ka baxsan ex kateedra falalka laga yaabo inay u baahan yihiin sixid faliyeed kuwa loo dhiibay tarjumaadda Erayga Ilaahay.
Hawsha tarjumaadda Erayga Ilaah si dhab ah ayaa loo aaminay oo keliya Magisterium ee Kaniisadda, taas oo ah, Pope iyo hoggaamiyaha kiniisadda isaga oo xidhiidh la leh. - CCC, 100
Laakiin neo-ultramontanists-ku waxay ku adkaysan doonaan in hoggaamiyaha kiniisaddu ay u hoggaansamaan wax kasta Pontiff wuxuu leeyahay - xitaa marka ay fiqi ahaan dhibaato leedahay. Waxay tixraaci doonaan Pope Leo XIII, oo qoray:
Sidaa darteed waxaa iska leh Pope inuu si awood leh u xukumo waxa ku jira hadallada xurmada leh, iyo sidoo kale waxa caqiidooyinka iswaafaqsan, iyo waxa khilaafsan, iyaga; iyo sidoo kale, sabab la mid ah, in la muujiyo waxa la aqbali karo inay sax yihiin, iyo waxa la diido inay yihiin wax aan qiimo lahayn; waxa loo baahan yahay in la sameeyo iyo waxa la iska ilaalinayo in la sameeyo, si loo helo badbaado weligeed ah. Waayo, haddii kale, ma jiro qof la hubo oo u tarjuma amarrada Eebbe, mana jiri doono hage ammaan ah oo dadka tusi doona qaabkii uu u noolaan lahaa. -Sapientiae Christianae, n 24
Peter-ka Bentakostiga ka dib… waa isla Butros oo baqdin ka qaba Yuhuudda, beeniyay xorriyadda masiixiga (Galatiya 2 11-14); Isagu markiiba waa dhagax iyo turunturooyin. Oo miyaanay sidaas ahayn taariikhda kaniisadda oo dhan in Pope, oo bedelay Butros, uu hal mar ahaa Petra iyo Skandalon - labadaba dhagaxa Ilaah iyo turunturooyinka? —POPE BENEDICT XVI, laga bilaabo Das neue Volk Gottes, P. 80ff
Iyadoo la raacayo Magisterium Sax ah
Soo-gudbinta diinta ee maskaxda iyo doonista waa in si gaar ah loo muujiyaa dhab ah magisterium ee Roman Pontiff, xitaa marka uusan hadlin ex cathedra... —N. 25, Vatican.va
Wax kasta oo dhaca, ha ka bixin waxbarista Magisteriumka runta ah ee Kaniisadda Ciiseyga. -Marwadayada Pedro Regis, Febraayo 3, 2022
Carruurtaygow, u duceeya Kaniisadda iyo wadaaddada quduuska ah inay had iyo jeer aamin ku ahaadaan Magisterium runta ah ee iimaanka. -Marwadeena Gisella Cardia, Febraayo 3, 2022
Carruur, u duceeya in Magisteriumka runta ah ee Kaniisadda aanu lumin. -Marwadayada Zaro ilaa Angela, July 8, 2023
Maxaa ka dhigan "runta" ama "saxda ah" magisterium ee baadari ama hoggaamiyaha kiniisaddu waa marka ay gudbiyaan wixii hore loogu dhiibay oo ay la socdaan "deebaajiga iimaanka."[14]Eeg Waa maxay "Magisterium runta ah" Siduu Masiixu ku amray rasuulladiisii ka hor kicitaankiisa:
Baadari ma aha madax-bannaanid buuxda, oo fikirkiisa iyo rabitaankiisuba sharci yihiin. Taas bedelkeeda, wasaaradda baadarigu waa dammaanad qaadka adeeca Masiixa iyo eraygiisa. -POPE BENEDICT XVI, Homily ee May 8, 2005; San Diego Union-Tribune
Tibaax kasta oo caqiidada ama dhaqanka aan waafaqsanayn Muujintii rabbaaniga ah, ka kooban Qorniinka xurmada leh iyo in dhaqanka Kaniisadda, ma noqon karaan layli dhab ah oo rasuul ama Petrine wasaaradda iyo waa in ay diidaan rumaysadka. —Cardinal Raymond Burke, oo hore uga tirsanaan jiray Saxiixa Rasuullada, oo ah awoodda ugu sarreysa garsoorka ee Kaniisadda hoosteeda Pope; Abriil 19, 2018; ncronline.org
... waxay heli karaan barakada koritaanka nimcada iyo guusha dadaalkooda akhlaaqda iyo talaabooyinkooda xiga ee jihada wanaagsan, laakiin maaha sida lamaanaha sababtoo ah isfaham la'aanta iyo suurtogalnimada nimcada noocaas ah. —Bishop Marian Eleganti, Diseembar 20, 2023; lifesitenews.com ka kath.net
Fiducia Ducooyinka does not belong to the “authentic Magisterium” and is therefore not binding because what is affirmed in it is not contained in the written or transmitted word of God and which the Church, the Roman Pontiff or the College of Bishops, either definitively, that is by solemn judgment, or with ordinary and universal Magisterium, proposes to believe as divinely revealed. One cannot even adhere to it with religious assent of will and intellect. —Theologian Father Nicola Bux, former consulter to the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith; January 25th, 2024; Edwardpentin.co.uk
Si kooban haddii aan u dhigo, madmadowga ula kac ah ee Ducooyinka Fiducia waxa uu albaabka u furayaa wax kasta oo ku saabsan dumin kasta oo guurka ah oo ay dalbadaan cadawga iimaanka, laakiin isla madmadowgaas macnihiisu waa dukumeenti aan ilko lahayn. -Fr. Dwight Longnecker, Diseembar 19, 2023; dwightlongenecker.com
Si kastaba ha ahaatee, in yar oo haddi ay jiraan ayaa ka doodaya qodobadan ku jira Baaqa, kuwaas oo runtii la jaan qaadaya Dhaqanka Muqadaska ah. Wadaaddaduna waxay had iyo jeer u duceeyaan shakhsiyaadka ka hor dukumeentigan. Hase yeeshe, waa "cusubnimada dhabta ah" ee qofku u ducaysan karo "lammaanaha", sida FS ay caddayso, iyada oo la iska indho-tiray xidhiidhka galmo ee gudaha ah taas oo ka dhigaysa lamaane marka hore. Si kale haddii loo dhigo, war-saxaafadeedkan cusub waa ku qasbaya kiniisadda inay aqbalaan xaaladdan wax u dhimaysa.
Digniinta Marwadayada iyo Joogitaanka…
Dabaylo liddi ku ah ayaa markabka weyn ka fogayn doona dekedda nabdoon, markab weyn oo burburayna waxa uu sababi doonaa dhimashada carruur badan oo sabool ah. Gacmahaaga i sii anna waxaan kuu hoggaamin doonaa wiilkayga Ciise. Oo weelkaasuna wuu ku warwareegi doonaa xadgudubka taliyaha, laakiinse Rabbigu dadkiisa wuu soo gargaari doonaa. —Janaayo 1, 2024
Shaqada sheydaanku wuxuu dhex gali doonaa xitaa kaniisada si qofku u arko kadinardiyaal ka soo hor jeeda kadinal, kiniisado diidan kiniisadaha. Wadaaddada i xurmeeya ayaa quudhsan doona oo ka soo horjeedsan doona kalsoonidooda kiniisadaha iyo meelahooda allabariga la eryi doonaa; Kaniisaddu way ka buuxsami doontaa kuwa aqbala tanaasullada oo jinku wuxuu culays ku saari doonaa wadaaddo badan iyo dad naftooda quduus looga dhigay inay ka tagaan adeegga Rabbiga -To Sr. Agnes Sasagawa ee Akita, Japan, Oktoobar 13th, 1973
The masduulaagii waa "maska hore, kan la yidhaahdo Ibliiska iyo Shaydaanka, khaa'iniinta dunida oo dhan"Rev 12:9). The isku dhac Waa mid aan sinnayn, masduulaaguna wuxuu u eg yahay inuu wax ka adkaanayo, oo isla weynaantiisuna way ku weyn tahay naag aan difaac lahayn oo dhib badan. Sii wad inaad ka fikirto Maryan, iyada oo og in ay "hooyo ahaan joogto oo ay la wadaagto dhibaatooyinka badan ee murugsan ee maanta haysta nolosha shakhsiyaadka, qoysaska, iyo quruumaha" oo ay "caawinayso dadka Masiixiyiinta ah ee halganka joogtada ah ee u dhexeeya wanaagga iyo sharka, si loo hubiyo in ay " ma dhaco, ama, hadduu dhacay, inuu 'soo sara kaco'." -Ecclesia ee Europe, n. 124, Juun 28, 2003
Carruur, ninna yuusan idin khiyaanayn.
Kii xaqnimo falaa waa xaq.
sida uu isagu xaq u leeyahay.
Ku alla kii dembaabaa Ibliis baa leh.
waayo Ibliisku tan iyo bilowgii wuu dembaabay.
Runtii, Wiilka Ilaah waxaa loo muujiyey inuu baabbi'iyo shuqullada Ibliiska.
In sidan,
carruurta Ilaah iyo carruurta Ibliisku waa la caddeeyey;
Ruuxii xaqnimada fali waaya Ilaahay baa iska leh.
iyo mid aan walaalkii jeclayn.
(Maanta Akhriska Koowaad)
Akhriska la xiriira
Sannad kale… waad ku mahadsan tahay
duco iyo taageero
Si aad ula safartid Mark gudaha The Hada Erey,
dhagsii calamada hoose si aad subscribe.
Emailkaaga cidna lama wadaagi doono.
Hadda ku jira Telegram. Guji:
Raac Mark iyo calaamadaha maalinlaha ah ee "MeWe:"
Dhageyso waxyaabaha soo socda:
Qoraalada
↑1 | Jan 4, 2024, Zenit |
---|---|
↑2 | Ducooyinka Fiducia, Oo ku saabsan Macnaha Xoolo-dhaqatada soo bandhigida barakooyinka |
↑3 | Emeritus Archbishop Charles Chaput |
↑4 | Fr. Thomas Weinandy |
↑5 | Bishop Athanasius Scheider |
↑6 | ccb.ca |
↑7 | tusaale. Bishop Peruvian wuxuu mamnuucay barakooyinka isku jinsiga ah; lifesitenews.com; Wadaaddadii Isbaanishka oo bilaabay codsi ah in FS la buriyo; infovaticana-com; Wadaaddadii Jarmalku waxay diideen FS inay yihiin kuwo is burinaya, cf. lifesitenews.com |
↑8 | cf. catholicherald.co.uk |
↑9 | Baadariyiinta ayaa sameeyay oo qaladaad sameeyay waana wax lala yaabo. Khalad la'aanta ayaa loo hayaa ex cathedra [“Kursiga” Butros, oo ah, ku dhawaaqida dogma ee ku saleysan Dhaqanka Xurmaysan]. No popes taariikhda Kaniisadda abid sameeyey ex cathedra khaladaadka. —Rev. Joseph Iannuzzi, fiqi iyo khabiir ku takhasusay wadaadada |
↑10 | Bishop Athanasius Schneider, onepeterfive.com |
↑11 | Wadaadka Joseph Iannuzzi, STL, S. Th.D., Warsidaha, Dayrta 2021; cf. Waxaa jira Hal Barque oo keliya |
↑12 | ma aha kala qaybsanaan, laakiin waxaa cad in laga sooco wixii aan waafaqsanayn Dhaqanka Muqadaska ah. |
↑13 | cf. Pope-ka ma noqon karaa bidco? |
↑14 | Eeg Waa maxay "Magisterium runta ah" |
↑15 | Pastor aeternus, Ch. 4:6 |
↑16 | cf. Soo Bandhigida Ammaanada Runta |
↑17 | cf. Pope-ka ma noqon karaa bidco? |
↑18 | "Ha quudhsanina erayada nebiyada, laakiin wax walba tijaabi; wanaagga xajiya…” (1 Tesaloniika 5:20-21) |